[Verse 1]
We got the news
Ithaca got snow
It was just that kind of day
All I know is that you've gone and left us here below
All I wish is that you'd stay
[Verse 2]
We leave this cursed city
The same way we come in
We trace the roads
On our way out
We shed our certainties like clothes
[Verse 3]
We thought this was our sacrifice
The world knew otherwise
And took you from us
Before your time
Right before our eyes
[Bridge]
We think we're walking home
But you can't go there unless it wants you
Stand out on the street
And still the destination haunts you
Is that where you are now?
To have believed that's truest love
Ain't it clearer now that we have love
And we don't have you?
[Verse 4]
It took this much to make me see
Still I barely understand
Love will always
Always be larger
And different from our plans
[Verse 5]
Love will never listen to us
Why should it?
Love knows the score
It builds better songs than we do
It sings a better metaphor