[Verse 1]

Lying on the floor listening to "Case of You" in your headphones

Little did I know, it meant more to me

And I couldn't see you wanted me to go home

Driving on the 405 talking 'bout our new apartment

Guess it's just hard when it meant more to me

In that passenger seat, now I live alone

[Pre-Chorus]

If I had cared a bit less

Would you care a bit more?

[Chorus]

Oh, Joni, how could you?

All that I ever did was try to love you

Never thought I'd see you lost in my rearview

Somehow so far, still breaking my heart

Over and over again

[Verse 2]

I count up all the ways that it's my fault but I nеver count yours

To keep you a sweet thing, to keep you from leaving

I called you to talk and you callеd me a chore

I don't know you anymore

[Chorus]

Joni, how could you?

All that I ever did was try to love you

Never thought I'd see you lost in my rearview

Somehow so far, still breaking my heart

Over and over again

[Post-Chorus]

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

Oh-oh, ooh

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

Oh-oh

[Bridge]

If I had cared a bit less

Would you care a bit more?

If it wasn't all for the best

Then what was it all for?

[Breakdown]

Oh Joni, how could you?

I was just trying to love you

Now you're lost in my rearview

Somehow so far, still breaking my heart

[Chorus]

Oh, Joni, how could you

Leave and take all of my favorite songs with you?

I don't hate you, but I hate that I miss you

Somehow so far, you're breaking my heart

Over and over again

[Post-Chorus]

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

Oh-oh, ooh

(It wasn't all for the best)

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

(What was it for?)

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

(If I had cared a bit less)

(Would you care a bit more?)

Oh-oh, ooh

Oh-oh, Joni, how could you?

(If it wasn't all for the best)

(What was it for?)

Oh-oh, ooh

[Outro]

Tell me what was it for?