[Gus]

You never wanted what I offered

You only offered what I had

When loving leaves you feeling bothered

You’d better just stay home with dad

The world is not your little dollhouse

You can’t stop playing when you want

‘Cause in the real world, they’re a fallout

No plastic food in restaurants

You never wanted misdirection

But spontaneity’s a bitch

And when I made that love connection

You never scratched me where I itched

You always loved Wisconsin winters

Though I can’t tell the months apart

But when you lift my chest in splinters

I saw the ice sheets matched your heart

[Amber]

You can’t imagine what it feels like

To feel the pressure of a fool

Whenever you pulled off that turnpike

We only played by your own rules

I gotta say you’re no magician

Your little melodies fell flat

I left you of my own volition

Of course you’ll never sing of that

[Gus]

You never wanted what I offered

[Amber]

I never wanted you at all

[Gus]

Then why did you say that you loved me?

[Amber]

Now we both know you took control

[Gus]

I thought you wanted my affection

[Amber]

Stop thinking all my thoughts for me

[Gus]

You know you’re nowhere near perfection

[Amber]

So this is how it’s going to be

[Gus]

I wanted you, why can’t you see?

[Amber]

So if you love me set me free