[Verse 1]

Remember when you said you loved me?

Remember when you said that it would all work out

We packed up and we left by morning

And everything you promised, it ain't happening now

[Pre-Chorus 1]

And I'm swirling, softly

Drifting like the cream in your coffee

And you're talking, calmly when...

[Chorus]

I'm scared to be on our own

When the thrill is gone

And I'm scared, thinking what we've done

To try to love someone

Baby, can you keep your promise?

Baby, can I keep you honest?

'Cause I'm scared

[Verse 2]

There's nothing in the sky above me

There's nothing strung below us, baby, if we fall

We're caught between a spark and lightning

We're caught between forever and nothing at all

[Pre-Chorus 2]

And I'm sorry, I love you

But even those words are getting see-through

And I'm losing it all to this feeling, baby

[Chorus]

I'm scared to be on our own

When the thrill is gone

And I'm scared, thinking what we've done

To try to love someone

Baby, can you keep your promise?

Baby, can I keep you honest?

'Cause I'm scared

[Bridge]

When you say you love me

When you say you love me (I'm scared)

Are we ever gonna be OK?

When you say you love me (I'm scared)

Are we ever really gonna feel safe?

When you say you love me (I'm scared)

Is there something I can say?

When you say you love me (I'm scared)

Is it better if I walk away?

When you say you love me

[Outro]

'Cause I'm scared to be on our own

And I'm scared, thinking what we've done

Baby, can you keep your promise?

Baby, can I keep you honest?

'Cause I'm scared