[Verse 1]
Maybe I'm a liar, like a Craigslist counterfeit, and you're the buyer
She said, "Boy, aren't you getting tired of trying to take a spark and turn it to a fire?"
Would it feel so different, if I did it in your room over Christmas?
Friends think it's sickenin'
Tell me to forget you, but I never seem to listen
[Chorus]
Honey, give me one more try
You could love me with the lights off
Closing both your eyes, pretending I could be somebody I'm not
You're always thinkin' 'bout the next best thing
And that's finŠµ, and you don't have to, but
Baby, let me call you minŠµ, just for one more night
One more night, baby
One more night
[Verse 2]
Do you have my back now?
What's the point in catchin' ya just to go and back out?
Love you like a job I'm tryna hold down
Pack the drawer, shut the door, it's time to cash out
[Chorus]
Honey, give me one more try
You could love me with the lights off
Closing both your eyes, pretending I could be somebody I'm not
You're always thinkin' 'bout the next best thing
And that's fine, and you don't have to, but
Baby, let me call you mine, just for one more night
One more night, baby
One more night
[Outro]
One more night, baby, let me try
One more night, let me try
Baby, just be mine
One more night, just be mine