[Verse 1]

Things are getting cold, I'm growing older

All alone here in the back of your mind

I miss the way you'd reach for me so easily

But now it's like you've left me behind

[Pre-Chorus]

Shut the door and you turned out the lights

And at first I was sure you would come back

But I'm not so sure anymore, is it over this time?

Tell me, did you lose your appetite?

[Chorus]

I feel like the Froot Loops, I feel like the Oatmeal

Up there on the top shelf nobody's touched

You loved me when we first met, baby, did you forget me?

Remember back then? How sweet it was, mmm-mmm

So, do you think you'll leave me here forever?

Or one day, will you dust me off like some forgetten treasure?

Like I'm brand-new, hold me like you used to

Like I'm still that boy who you used to love, mmm-mmm

[Verse 2]

I'm holdin' onto hope and tryin' to cope

With knowing I'm no longer what you desire

But I want you to know that even though you let me go

My love will never expire

[Pre-Chorus]

Shut the door, then you turned out the lights

And I keep waitin' for you to want me

But I'm not so sure anymore, is it over this time?

Tell me, did you lose your appetite?

[Chorus]

I feel like the Froot Loops, I feel like the Oatmeal

Up there on the top shelf nobody's touched

You loved me when we first met, baby, did you forget me?

Remember back then? How sweet it was, mmm-mmm

So, do you think you'll leave me here forever?

Or one day, will you dust me off like some forgetten treasure?

Like I'm brand-new, hold me like you used to

Like I'm still that boy who you used to love, mmm-mmm

[Bridge]

I miss you every morning, no breakfast, ain't the same

Yeah, I keep waitin' for you, tell me, is it too late?

Yeah, I've been waitin' for you, every night, every day

Tell me, is it too late?

[Chorus]

I feel like the Froot Loops, I feel like the Oatmeal

Up there on the top shelf nobody's touched

You loved me when we first met, baby, did you forget me?

Remember back then? How sweet it was, mmm-mmm

So, do you think you'll leave me here forever?

Or one day, will you dust me off like some forgetten treasure?

Like I'm brand-new, hold me like you used to

Like I'm still that boy who you used to love

[Outro]

Treasure, like I'm brand-new, hold me like you used to

Like I'm still that boy who you used to love, mmm-mmm